Entrepreneurs Of New York
Original Lifestyle

After Consulting in 23 Countries, Roberta's Alum Anthony Falco Opens His Own Williamsburg Pizzeria

Pizzeria the Pantheon Bar, from former Roberta's pizzaiolo Anthony Falco and partner Mateo Vivas, opens Nov. 20 at 276 Grand Street. What's on the menu, how they found the space, and why a globe-trotting consultant chose one neighborhood restaurant over scale.

After Consulting in 23 Countries, Roberta's Alum Anthony Falco Opens His Own Williamsburg Pizzeria

NEW YORK — For a decade, Anthony Falco helped other people open pizzerias. Now he’s opening his own.

Pizzeria the Pantheon Bar, from the pizzaiolo who helped make Roberta’s in Bushwick a destination, opens Friday, Nov. 20, at 276 Grand Street in Williamsburg, between Roebling and Havemeyer streets, Eater NY reported. Falco and his business partner, Roberta’s front-of-house alum Mateo Vivas, own the restaurant outright.

From Consultant to Owner

Falco started making dough at Roberta’s when it opened in 2008 and became its “pizza czar,” a title that later became the name of his cookbook. Around 10 years ago he set out to open his own place, Grub Street reported, but instead became a global consultant, advising “dozens and dozens” of pizzerias in more than 23 countries, from the Dominican Republic and Kuwait to Taipei and Mongolia. He also became a partner in one, Bráz Elettrica, in Brazil.

What brought him home was family. “Ten years on the road got a little old,” he told Grub Street. “I want to be making pizza with my family.”

For founders in any industry, the arc is a familiar one: build expertise on someone else’s payroll, sell that expertise as a service, then finally bet it on a business you own. Falco told Eater he had been “looking at spaces for 10 years.”

How They Found the Space

The location came from a line, not a broker. According to Eater, the partners spotted the for-lease sign while waiting for a table at I Cavallini down the block. Grub Street reported that the vacant storefront, the former June’s House of Crystals, checked their boxes: a clean basement, a reasonable size and a backyard.

It was a bare room when they found it. Eater describes concrete floors and cinder blocks, now replaced with terrazzo, wainscoting, caned chairs and a long bar meant to evoke a Roman pizzeria. The centerpiece is a decades-old wooden bar their builder found at a tortilla company in Bushwick, which was taken apart and rebuilt on Grand Street.

The build-out leaned local, too. Falco mocked up the pizza station in cardboard at home and had it designed in Detroit, and a steel fabricator around the corner from his apartment built the rest, Eater reported. The backyard patio is planned as a second phase.

What’s on the Menu

Pizzas will be priced in the $20s. “We don’t want people talking about the price,” Falco told Eater. “There are no $40 pizzas.”

The opening lineup includes a sour cream and onion pie with Vermont crème fraîche and Greenmarket onions and chives. Dough is made with Cairnspring Mills flour from the Pacific Northwest and leavened with Falco’s 10-year-old sourdough starter, which he has carried around the world. Mozzarella is stretched to order, and pies bake in a three-deck Moretti electric oven, the kind Falco has installed in pizzerias from Mongolia to India.

There’s focaccia by the slice or whole, filled with options like mortadella or cherry tomatoes and olives, and sides like beans and greens. Falco is also inviting collaborators from abroad. The first, with Defne and Emre Kasrat of Gusina in Istanbul, launches a Turkish-inspired pie on Wednesday, Nov. 25, with smoked rib-eye from Brent Young of the Meat Hook, finished with pomegranate molasses. It will stay on the menu for a month, Eater reported.

At the bar, Vivas is pouring Italian-leaning wines and plans cocktails like smoked-tomato Negronis and guanciale-washed martinis, plus big-format sparkling waters.

The Name

The name nods to Rome’s Pantheon, where Queen Margherita, namesake of the margherita pizza, is buried. It also references the Pantheon Bar in Alejandro Jodorowsky’s 1973 film The Holy Mountain, a place that distracts seekers on the road to enlightenment.

One Restaurant, On Purpose

Plenty of New York food entrepreneurs are chasing fast-casual concepts and multiple locations. Falco says that isn’t the plan. “We’re not looking to optimize and scale — it’s a neighborhood restaurant,” he told Grub Street. He described sit-down pizzerias like Patsy’s, Grimaldi’s, Juliana’s and John’s of Bleecker as his inspiration. “New York has become known for the slice for sure, but it started with simple sit-down pizzerias.”

It’s a useful counterpoint in a tough year for New York restaurants. Keeping prices in check, owning the business outright and building one room well is its own kind of strategy.

If You Go

Pizzeria the Pantheon Bar, 276 Grand Street, Williamsburg. Open Wednesday through Sunday, 5 to 10 p.m., starting Nov. 20. Walk-ins only for now, according to Eater.

← More Lifestyle