Entrepreneurs Of New York
Original Small Business

Two New York Employment Laws Hit Small Businesses This Season: Personnel File Access Is Live, and 'Stay-or-Pay' Deals End Dec. 19

Since Nov. 8, New York employers of every size must hand over personnel files within five business days of a written request. On Dec. 19, the Trapped at Work Act bans most new 'stay-or-pay' repayment agreements. What each law requires, what's still unsettled, and a year-end checklist for small employers.

Two New York Employment Laws Hit Small Businesses This Season: Personnel File Access Is Live, and 'Stay-or-Pay' Deals End Dec. 19

NEW YORK — If you run a small business in New York, two state employment laws are landing on your desk before the end of the year. One is already in effect. The other starts in about a month. Neither has an exemption for small employers.

The first, a new personnel records law, gives current and former employees the right to see what’s in their files. The second, the Trapped at Work Act, bans most “stay-or-pay” agreements that make workers repay training or other costs if they leave early. Here’s what to know.

Law One: Employees Can Now See Their Personnel Files

Gov. Kathy Hochul signed New York Labor Law Section 210-b on Sept. 9, and it took effect on Nov. 8, according to Proskauer Rose. It applies to public and private employers of every size with employees working in New York, likely including remote employees, and has no industry exemptions, law firm Kleinberg Kaplan wrote on Nov. 10.

Under the law, employers must:

  • Provide a free copy of the personnel record within five business days of a written request from a current or former employee
  • Allow at least two reviews per calendar year, with reviews prompted by newly added negative information not counting toward that limit
  • Notify an employee within 10 days of adding information that has been, is being or may be used to negatively affect their employment, promotion, transfer, pay or discipline
  • Keep the complete record during employment and for three years after it ends

A “personnel record” is broad. It includes the employee’s name, address and date of birth, job title and description, pay, start date and termination notices, job application and résumé, signed waivers, performance evaluations, written warnings, probationary periods and other disciplinary documents, per Proskauer. Kleinberg Kaplan notes it also covers records a third party such as a payroll vendor or professional employer organization keeps for you.

If you and an employee can’t agree to fix a disputed entry, the employee can add a written statement to the file. Violations carry fines of $500 to $2,500 each, enforced by the state attorney general, and retaliation is prohibited.

What’s unsettled: In her signing memo, Hochul said she’d reached an agreement with legislators to clarify that employers don’t have to create files or new documents and that covered records are only those used in employment decisions. Those amendments are expected in the 2027 session. Kleinberg Kaplan’s advice is to comply with the law as written until they pass.

Law Two: Most ‘Stay-or-Pay’ Agreements End Dec. 19

The Trapped at Work Act bans employers from requiring workers or applicants to sign “employment promissory notes” as a condition of employment, meaning agreements to pay the employer if they leave before a set date. The state Department of Labor says the law takes effect Dec. 19, 2026, and covers all employers and all employees, full-time, part-time or seasonal.

It applies only to new agreements, or new or amended terms in existing ones, signed on or after Dec. 19. Existing agreements generally aren’t affected, Fisher Phillips noted after reviewing the agency’s new guidance.

Some arrangements are still allowed, according to the Labor Department:

  • Tuition for a transferable credential, such as a widely recognized license or certificate, if the agreement is written and separate from the job offer, discloses the amount up front, prorates repayment and waives it if you terminate the employee for reasons other than misconduct. Employer-specific training and mandated safety training don’t count.
  • Sign-on bonuses, relocation help and similar incentives not tied to job performance, but repayment can only be required if the employee quits or is fired for misconduct, and not if the job was misrepresented.
  • Property the employee voluntarily bought or leased from you, such as tools.
  • Truly voluntary agreements that aren’t a condition of taking or keeping the job.

Penalties run from $1,000 to $5,000, depending on factors including business size and good faith. There’s no private right to sue, but a worker who successfully defends against an employer’s suit to enforce a voided agreement can recover attorney’s fees.

Why This Matters for Small Businesses

Big companies have HR departments. Many New York restaurants, salons and startups have an owner, a manager and a shared drive, where warnings live in text threads and training agreements get copied from old templates. Any business that pays for certifications or offers sign-on bonuses should review its paperwork.

A Year-End Checklist

  1. Find your files. HR software, payroll vendor, email, paper folders.
  2. Set up a five-day process. Decide who receives written requests, who pulls the file and who reviews it before it goes out. Kleinberg Kaplan suggests checking files for confidential business or privileged material.
  3. Write a notice routine. Decide how you’ll tell employees within 10 days when a warning or negative review goes in their file.
  4. Audit repayment terms before Dec. 19. Pull offer letters and training, bonus, relocation and tuition agreements. Anything you plan to sign, renew or amend after Dec. 19 needs to fit an exception.
  5. Train managers on accurate documentation and the retaliation ban.
  6. Ask for help. Talk to an employment lawyer about anything unclear. This article is general information, not legal advice.

It’s easier to do this now than the day a former employee sends a written request.

← More Small Business