Entrepreneurs Of New York
Original Lifestyle

Erewhon's First Public New York Tonic Bar Opens Inside Kith Women at 644 Broadway. What the $21 Smoothie Shop-in-Shop Teaches Local Brands

Los Angeles organic grocer Erewhon opened its first public New York outlet on Nov. 20: a walk-in Tonic Bar inside Kith Women's flagship at 644 Broadway, with $21 smoothies and lines that started at 6:30 a.m. Why the brand chose a shop-in-shop instead of a store, and what New York food and retail founders can take from the launch.

Erewhon's First Public New York Tonic Bar Opens Inside Kith Women at 644 Broadway. What the $21 Smoothie Shop-in-Shop Teaches Local Brands

NEW YORK — Erewhon didn’t open a grocery store in New York. It opened a smoothie counter inside someone else’s store, and people lined up before sunrise anyway.

The Los Angeles organic grocer’s first public New York location, The Tonic Bar by Erewhon, opened Nov. 20 inside the Kith Women flagship at 644 Broadway. According to the announcement, it’s Erewhon’s first standalone Tonic Bar concept outside California. It’s walk-in only and open seven days a week, Monday through Saturday from 8 a.m. to 8 p.m. and Sunday from 8 a.m. to 7 p.m., according to Kith.

What’s on the Menu, and What It Costs

The bar serves signature tonics, superfood smoothies, bowls, juices, cold-pressed shots, coffee and ceremonial-grade matcha. To mark the opening, Erewhon launched the Erewhon State of Mind Smoothie, a red-apple-inspired blend of organic cold-pressed apple juice, winter spices and goji berries sold only at this location. Erewhon says the smoothie supports the Bowery Mission, the nonprofit serving New Yorkers experiencing homelessness.

The prices are the point of most of the coverage. The New York Post reported $21 smoothies, including the Strawberry Glaze associated with Hailey Bieber, and $13 lattes, before tax. It counted more than 29 possible $1 add-ins, which can push a drink to $30 or more. Fans started lining up as early as 6:30 a.m., and some customers waited 50 minutes to an hour to get inside.

Why a Counter and Not a Store

Erewhon currently has 13 full grocery stores, all in California, the Post reported when the opening was announced. Its next announced stores are in California too: a reopened Pacific Palisades location, Costa Mesa and Downtown Los Angeles.

Instead of signing a big-box grocery lease in one of the country’s most expensive retail markets, Erewhon is starting with its highest-profile product in a space that already draws shoppers. Kith described the arrangement as reflecting “a longstanding friendship between Erewhon and Kith.”

“New York has always felt like a natural place for Erewhon to grow, and we’re pleased to introduce a new Tonic Bar concept to the city for everyone to enjoy,” CEO Tony Antoci said in the announcement.

The partnership already had a test run. According to the Post, Kith founder and CEO Ronnie Fieg opened a drinks-only Erewhon Tonic Bar in late 2025 at Kith Ivy, his private padel, wellness and social club in the West Village. Members pay $45,000 initiation fees and $10,000 in annual dues. Non-members could order some drinks through Postmates and Uber Eats, in limited quantities and only within a one-mile radius. The Broadway counter is the first one open to anyone.

Not Everyone Is Sold

The Post’s reporter compared a $16 Almond Butter Blast unfavorably with a $7 smoothie from Urban Valley Natural Market in Bushwick. One first-time customer, Manhattan content creator Fredy Tista, told the paper, “It’s not like the city doesn’t already have great spots.” The Post framed the open question as whether a brand built on Los Angeles exclusivity can win over a city that already makes this product, sometimes for a fraction of the price.

Lessons for New York Food and Retail Founders

You don’t need a cult following to borrow from this launch.

  • Test a format before a footprint. A counter inside an established store let Erewhon enter New York with one product line instead of a full grocery operation. Local brands can try the same thing through pop-ups, kiosks or a corner of a complementary shop before committing to a lease. Our coverage of record-low Manhattan retail availability shows why that matters for anyone hunting for a storefront.
  • Pick a host whose customers already want what you sell. Erewhon and Kith pair wellness with fashion for an overlapping crowd. A shop-in-shop works when the host’s traffic is your target customer.
  • Make one thing only available here. The location-exclusive smoothie gave fans a reason to show up on day one. Brittney Ava, an early arrival, told the Post, “People know that they can only get this here, and that the smoothie is rare.”
  • Tie the launch to the neighborhood. The Bowery Mission tie-in, and free bouquets from New York florist and plant shop PlantShed for people waiting in line, gave a West Coast brand local partners on opening day.
  • Know that price is your story. At $21, coverage was as much about the cost as the product. If you charge a premium, be ready to explain why, and to compete with the $7 neighborhood shop down the street.

We’ve watched a run of out-of-town food brands test New York this month, from Voodoo Doughnut in Union Square to Japan’s Sushiro in Times Square. Erewhon took the lightest path in: a counter, a partner and one exclusive drink. Whether the lines last after opening week is the test.

← More Lifestyle