Entrepreneurs Of New York
Original Real Estate

Vimeo, Future and Dolce & Gabbana All Moved Their NYC Headquarters This Month. None Went Far. What Mid-Size Tenants Can Learn

Three companies signed Midtown headquarters leases of 13,000 to 21,000 square feet in early November, and two of them moved only a block or so. What the deals say about rents, renovated buildings and negotiating power for growing New York companies.

Vimeo, Future and Dolce & Gabbana All Moved Their NYC Headquarters This Month. None Went Far. What Mid-Size Tenants Can Learn

NEW YORK — The big Manhattan office headlines usually belong to banks taking six floors. But some of the most useful deals for growing companies are the smaller ones, and early November produced three of them in Midtown: a tech company, a publisher and a fashion house, each signing for a single floor or less for their New York headquarters.

What stands out is how short the moves were. Two of the three relocated within a block or two of where they already were. That says a lot about how growing companies are thinking about office space right now.

The Three Deals

Vimeo at 5 Penn Plaza. The video platform, owned by Italian tech firm Bending Spoons, signed a 15,172-square-foot lease on part of the 15th floor of Haymes Investment Company’s 5 Penn Plaza, Commercial Observer reported. It’s moving from the 10th floor of 330 West 34th Street, about half a block away. Rent and lease length weren’t disclosed. Vimeo was represented by Avison Young, and its general counsel, John Fogleman, credited the brokers in a statement: “Finding the right space was only part of the equation. Equally important was negotiating a lease that made sense for our business.”

Future at 25 West 39th Street. The British publisher behind Live Science, Marie Claire and Homes & Gardens is taking the entire 13,000-square-foot second floor of Thor Equities’ building one block south of Bryant Park, according to Commercial Observer. The 10-year lease carries an asking rent of $70 per square foot, per a source familiar with the deal. Future is moving from Bush Tower at 130 West 42nd Street, a short walk around the park, where it had signed for 16,000 square feet in 2021. Thor said the deal brings the building to full occupancy.

Dolce & Gabbana at 551 Fifth Avenue. The Italian fashion house signed a long-term, 21,000-square-foot lease for the full ninth floor of The Feil Organization’s building near Grand Central for its New York headquarters, the New York Real Estate Journal reported. Feil says the 430,156-square-foot property has logged more than 200,000 square feet of new deals during its repositioning, including the National Women’s Soccer League’s headquarters.

What the Deals Say

Staying close is the default. Vimeo moved half a block. Future moved around the corner of Bryant Park. When employees’ commutes, client habits and neighborhood routines are built around a location, the cheapest move is often the shortest one. It also means a tenant’s real leverage isn’t threatening to leave Manhattan. It’s the half-dozen buildings within a few blocks competing for the same floor.

Renovated buildings are winning. 5 Penn’s recent redevelopment added a Gensler-designed lobby and amenity center, a conference center, a fitness center and a dog-friendly roof deck, according to Avison Young. Feil has been repositioning 551 Fifth. Thor filled 25 West 39th. Mid-size companies are trading up into refreshed buildings rather than settling for older space with fewer perks.

Smaller can be an upgrade. Future’s new floor is 13,000 square feet, compared with the 16,000 it signed for at Bush Tower in 2021. Taking less space in a building that’s been refreshed or fully leased is a trade many teams that come in a few days a week are weighing.

Know the benchmark. Midtown’s average office asking rent was $85.53 per square foot in the third quarter, according to a CBRE figure cited by Commercial Observer. Future’s reported $70 asking rent sits well below that, a reminder that asking averages blend trophy towers with older buildings, and that a second floor near Bryant Park prices differently than a 40th-floor view.

The Penn District is tightening. Avison Young’s third-quarter report found total availability in the Penn Station submarket fell to 11.9%. We wrote about another tenant betting on the area, the Carnegie Diner at 7 Penn Plaza, last week, and about the broader jump in Manhattan leasing in October.

A Checklist for Growing Companies

If your lease is up in the next 18 months, these deals suggest a few moves:

  1. Start early. Availability is falling in the best-renovated buildings, so give yourself a year or more.
  2. Get your own broker. All three tenants used tenant-side brokers. The landlord’s broker works for the landlord.
  3. Price the whole package. Ask about free rent, a landlord-funded build-out, and shared amenities like conference centers that let you lease less private space.
  4. Shop the block, not the borough. List every comparable building within a short walk of your current office, then make them compete.
  5. Right-size honestly. Count how many people are in the office on your busiest day, not your headcount, before deciding how much space you need.
  6. Watch the term. A 10-year lease like Future’s can buy better economics, but make sure it includes the flexibility a growing company needs, such as the right to sublease or expand.

The lesson from November’s Midtown deals isn’t that companies are fleeing or flocking. It’s that they’re getting pickier, and that the best terms go to tenants who start early and know their options.

← More Real Estate